Photos by Ella Manthey
A gift card is an easy present to give. Choosing the right one, however, can be surprisingly difficult. A favorite restaurant? A neighborhood shop? A place someone has been meaning to try? And when a company is buying gifts for hundreds of employees, knowing where each person would like to spend that money is nearly impossible.
For St. Louis entrepreneur Mark Sawyier, that challenge pointed to a much bigger opportunity: What if one gift card could connect recipients with dozens of local businesses, allowing them to decide where to spend it?
That idea became GiftBetter. The platform brings participating St. Louis-area businesses together in one marketplace, giving individuals and companies a way to send a gift that recipients can use at a local favorite or exchange for another participating business.
The goal is straightforward: make supporting local businesses as convenient as buying a gift card from a national brand, while keeping more of that spending in the St. Louis region.
Sawyier estimates that roughly $2 billion is spent on gift cards in the region each year, with approximately 90 percent going to national and global brands. If GiftBetter could redirect even 10 percent of the dollars currently leaving the local economy, he says, that would mean about $180 million annually for area businesses.
“How could I not give this a go?” Sawyier says. “The success of this business has a one-to-one relationship with economic impact.”
GiftBetter founder Mark Sawyier poses inside Scout’s, one of the platform’s merchants.
Making Local Gifting Easier
The idea grew out of Sawyier’s experience with Bonfyre, his previous company, which operates a gift card program for corporate clients. Customers appreciated the convenience of the program but started asking for local options.
That feedback prompted Sawyier to look more closely at the gift card market and the barriers that make local gift cards less convenient to give.
“If I want to give you a local gift card, two things have to happen,” he says. “I have to transact one-to-one, so I have to go to that business and buy their gift card. And then two, I need to know what your favorite restaurant is, and a lot of times I don’t.”
For consumers, that can mean making an extra stop or guessing where someone would like to visit. For employers purchasing gifts for hundreds or thousands of people, the challenge is even greater, making a national retailer seem like the simplest option.
GiftBetter removes much of that guesswork. A gift-giver selects an amount, adds a personal message, and can suggest a local business. The recipient can keep that selection or swap it for another participating merchant. Gifts can be sent digitally or as physical cards, with personalization options that include photos, videos, and GIFs.
The flexibility is central to the concept: The person giving the gift doesn’t have to know exactly where the recipient wants to go, and the recipient gets an opportunity to discover somewhere new.
For businesses, GiftBetter is designed to function as an additional sales channel rather than a replacement for an existing gift-card program. Merchants connect their current gift-card systems to the platform, making their gift cards available to a broader audience without changing how they sell directly to customers.
According to the company’s vendor materials, businesses can list for free and pay a 6.75 percent fee only on gift cards sold through GiftBetter, including credit card processing. The platform also offers reporting and payouts to participating merchants.
Sawyier says that approach reflects a shift in the gift-card technology landscape. In the past, independent businesses often needed a separate provider to manage gift cards. As gift card capabilities became more common in point-of-sale systems, GiftBetter could integrate with the technology merchants already use instead of asking them to adopt another system.
“That means a merchant can sign up in five minutes,” he says. “And that means that they don’t need to pay anything if it doesn’t work.”
Brandon Panosh (pictured left) and Elliott Brown, co-owners of Scout’s, pose in the restaurant’s kitchen.
A Collective Approach to Local Business
For independent businesses, the opportunity extends beyond an individual gift card sale. Being part of a shared marketplace can introduce a business to customers who might not otherwise encounter it.
That’s one of the benefits that appealed to Elliott Brown, co-owner of Scout’s, a local business participating in the GiftBetter network. Brown sees value in having a platform promote multiple independent businesses at once, rather than requiring each business to reach new customers on its own.
“If you have a platform out there selling things for you, without you having to do any work, that’s just a big help for any business,” Brown says. “Especially small businesses, where every dollar really matters to you.”
The platform also gives gift recipients a reason to explore. Someone who might hesitate to spend their own money at an unfamiliar restaurant or shop could be more willing to try it with a gift card. And because recipients can divide their spending among different participating businesses, one gift can lead to several visits.
Brown says that kind of discovery can benefit an entire business community, particularly in the restaurant industry, where operators often recommend one another to customers.
“The more good restaurants and thriving restaurants the city has in general, we’re all going to benefit from that,” Brown says.
Brown and his business partners have also made a deliberate commitment to Downtown St. Louis, Downtown West, and Midtown. Having lived in the Midtown area on and off for about a decade, they’ve watched the neighborhoods evolve and want to contribute to its continued growth.
For Brown, a thriving neighborhood is one where customers have reasons to stay. If one restaurant is full, another great option is just down the street.
“The more that we can get people in this area, the better for growing Downtown, growing Midtown,” he says. “We very specifically wanted to be in Downtown and Midtown and be a part of bringing it back to life.”
That neighborhood-level impact is also part of what Sawyier sees as a potential application for GiftBetter. The platform can be used to direct gifts toward communities or groups of businesses, allowing an organization or individual to encourage spending in a specific district.
A company could give employees a gift designated for participating businesses in Maplewood, for example, or someone could give a gift intended to introduce a recipient to the businesses along South Grand. In that way, the marketplace could support not only individual merchants but also the commercial districts that connect them.
Built in St. Louis, with Room to Grow
Sawyier has spent more than 20 years in St. Louis after moving to the region to attend WashU. GiftBetter is his fourth business, and he says the region has played an important role in his entrepreneurial journey.
When he launched Bonfyre, some of his earliest customers included major companies such as the St. Louis Rams, Budweiser, and Express Scripts. He credits connections with people invested in the region’s success for helping him get those opportunities.
“There’s a really genuine and large number of people here who care about making St. Louis better,” he says. “We don’t always have all the answers. We don’t always agree on stuff. But I think one thing that is clear is a lot of people care and a lot of people put energy behind it.”
That sense of local investment makes GiftBetter particularly meaningful to him. Unlike some of his previous ventures, he says, the company’s growth is directly tied to the economic impact it can create for the community.
The company is also benefiting from a technology shift that has changed how quickly a startup can get off the ground. Sawyier says artificial intelligence has helped his small team build the platform far faster and with fewer resources than would have been possible in the past.
The team didn’t write its first line of code until June 1, he says. With AI supporting development, a project that he estimates could previously have required 18 months and a team of 13 people was built by a team of four.
“We’re not using AI to build AI to sell AI,” Sawyier says. “We’re using AI to help local businesses and their communities capture more gift card spend.”
For a business model that depends on volume and operates on relatively tight margins, he says, keeping development costs and overhead down is especially important.
GiftBetter’s immediate focus is continuing to establish traction in St. Louis, with the holiday season serving as an important test of whether consumers and companies will embrace the model. Sawyier has identified Kansas City as a potential next market, with the longer-term goal of expanding into additional cities across the country.
Corporate gifting could be a significant part of that growth. Companies can send gifts to employees and clients in one order, while GiftBetter’s partnership with Bonfyre helps accommodate recipients outside its local markets through a catalog of more than 800 gift cards across 80 countries.
The platform’s current corporate offering also allows businesses to incorporate their own branding and messaging into gifts, extending the idea beyond a simple gift card purchase.
Ultimately, Sawyier believes the biggest challenge is getting people to try a different approach to gifting. Once they understand the flexibility and local impact, he says, the value becomes clear.
And the benefit isn’t limited to the person receiving the gift. A visit to a new restaurant, a purchase at an independent shop, or an afternoon spent exploring a neighborhood can create a connection between a customer and a business that lasts beyond the value of the card.
“GiftBetter leads to a real-world experience,” Sawyier says. “When I give you a gift, you’re going to go out and have a meal or shop at a local place.”
In a season when gift cards are a popular choice for both consumers and employers, GiftBetter is making the case that convenience and community support don’t have to be competing priorities. One gift, Sawyier hopes, can help someone discover a new favorite local business while also keeping more dollars in the St. Louis community.